How Should I Start Magic: The Gathering?

Accolades Collectibles — 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187

Magic at our shop is singles, sealed product, and accessories. Start with a deck you will play, or sealed product from a set you like, and sleeve the cards before you shuffle. If you want to sell or trade, bring them to the same buy desk as everything else.

Published 2026-11-18. Updated 2026-11-18.

What we carry

The Magic pages on this site are for singles, sealed product, and accessories stocked at the Warrenton store and listed online. What is in the case today is what we can hand you. Ask if you are looking for a specific card.

Collecting versus playing

Players need a deck that follows the current rules for the format they play. Those rules change, so use Wizards of the Coast's own format notes if you are heading to an event. Collectors can ignore the format and buy the art they want. Either way, sleeves are what keep a card from showing up played after one night.

Checklist

Decide whether the card is for a deck or a binder.

Buy the single if you need that card.

Sleeve before you shuffle.

Bring a collection in if you want an offer. Call first if it is large.

Singles, sealed product, and sleeves

The Magic page on this site is singles, sealed product, and accessories stocked at the Warrenton store and listed online. A single is the card a deck is missing. Sealed product is packs or a box from a set. Accessories are the sleeves and boxes that keep those cards from whitening. Ask at the counter if you are looking for a specific card. If it is in the case, we can hand it to you.

Players and collectors use the same cardboard. A player needs cards that fit the format of the event they are attending. Those lists change, so use Wizards of the Coast's current format notes for a tournament. A collector can buy the art they want and ignore the format. Either person should sleeve the card before it is shuffled.

Building the first small pile

Pick a deck you will actually play, or a set whose look you like. Buy the singles you are missing instead of hoping a pack contains four copies of one card. Count the deck the way that format asks you to count it. Sleeve every card. Play a game. Change a few cards. That is the same loop as any first deck in the shop.

If you are selling Magic, it comes to the same buy desk as Pokémon and sports cards. We review collections in person. Call first when the collection is large, and bring a photo ID. Offers depend on eligibility, demand, market value, condition, and staff approval, which is the rule on the trade-status page. Nothing changes hands until you agree.

Mistakes

Shuffling a deck bare. Buying a box when the list called for specific singles. Assuming a card is legal in an event because a video used it last year. Storing the deck in a rubber band. Bring the list to the counter and we will see what the wall has.

Visit the store or shop online

Accolades Collectibles is at 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187. Open daily, 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM. Call (703) 901-1582 or email support@accoladescollectibles.com. Walk-ins are welcome.

Flat $8.99 UPS/USPS shipping to the contiguous US (lower 48 + DC). Free local pickup in Warrenton. There is no free-shipping threshold.

Corrections

If something here is wrong, email support@accoladescollectibles.com with the page address. We will fix it and change the updated date. How we source and date claims is on the editorial policy.

Accolades Collectibles is an independent retailer. We are not operated, sponsored, or endorsed by The Pokémon Company, Nintendo, Wizards of the Coast, Konami, Panini, Topps, PSA, BGS, or CGC. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Frequently asked questions

Do you sell Magic cards?

Yes. Singles, sealed product, and accessories, in the shop and online when they are in stock.

Do you buy Magic cards?

We review collections in person, including other TCGs besides Pokémon. Call ahead for a large collection and bring a photo ID.

What should a new player buy first?

Cards you will play, plus sleeves. A random pile of packs is fun and a slow way to build a deck.

Can I get a Magic card graded?

Yes, if you want a slab. We submit to PSA, BGS, and CGC and confirm the fee first.

Where do I see stock?

In the shop, and on the Magic section of the site.

Do you host Magic events?

In-store events are listed on the events page when they are scheduled. The shop is open daily either way.

Can I get a Magic card graded?

Yes. We submit cards to PSA, BGS, and CGC and confirm the fee before we send them.