PSA vs BGS vs CGC: Which Grading Company?

Accolades Collectibles — 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187

PSA, BGS, and CGC each seal a card in a labeled holder. PSA is the holder many buyers already know, BGS prints subgrades for centering, corners, edges, and surface, and CGC is widely used for trading card games. We submit to all three from the Warrenton counter, after we look at the card with you, and we confirm that company's current fee before we send anything.

Published 2026-11-18. Updated 2026-11-18.

How to choose

Choose the company whose holder you want on that card. Collectors who want the label most buyers already recognize usually start with PSA. If you want centering, corners, edges, and surface printed as four numbers, ask about BGS. CGC is the holder many trading-card collectors pick. We submit to all three from the Warrenton counter, the same way the grading page describes it, and we confirm that company's current fee before the card leaves.

Checklist

Name the card and why you want it slabbed.

Pick a company for the holder, not for a hoped-for number.

Ask for the current fee and turnaround.

Leave played bulk in sleeves.

What each holder shows you

All three companies examine a card and seal it in a holder with a grade on a 1 to 10 scale. PSA's label is the one many buyers already recognize when they shop for slabs. BGS prints subgrades, so the label shows centering, corners, edges, and surface as separate scores along with the final grade. CGC is widely used for trading card games, and the grading page lists it next to PSA and BGS as a submission we handle.

The store FAQ says we handle PSA, BGS, and CGC grading submissions and drop-off is in the store. The grading page says we prepare, pack, and ship the submission, and the company assigns the grade. PSA submissions we send go on the shop account, so you do not need your own PSA membership. We confirm the current fee and turnaround, which those companies set, before the card leaves.

How a choice sounds at the counter

If you say you want the holder people ask for by name, we start with PSA and the service level that fits the card. If you say you want the four subgrades on the label, we talk about BGS. If the card is a Pokémon, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh, One Piece, or Lorcana card and you want CGC's holder, we talk about CGC. You can bring one card or a small stack. We look at each one.

Sports slabs already in the case can also be SGC, because the sports pages list SGC among the graded cards we stock. Submitting a raw card is a different sentence: the grading page names PSA, BGS, and CGC. Read the holder on a slab you are buying so you know which company sealed it, and check the cert number on that company's lookup.

A practical comparison

Bring the same card and tell us the job. Protection in a recognized holder, subgrades on the label, or a TCG holder. We will match that job to a company and a service level and tell you the current total. Cards ship insured for declared value in both directions and are logged at intake, which is what the PSA grading page says. When the slab returns, you pick it up at the shop.

Look at the card before you choose. A crease is visible without a company. A clean card is the one worth the conversation. We will tell you if it is a poor candidate for the fee. The label that comes back is the company's grade. Pick the slab up at the Warrenton shop when it returns to the counter.

Visit the store or shop online

Accolades Collectibles is at 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187. Open daily, 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM. Call (703) 901-1582 or email support@accoladescollectibles.com. Walk-ins are welcome.

Flat $8.99 UPS/USPS shipping to the contiguous US (lower 48 + DC). Free local pickup in Warrenton. There is no free-shipping threshold.

Corrections

If something here is wrong, email support@accoladescollectibles.com with the page address. We will fix it and change the updated date. How we source and date claims is on the editorial policy.

Accolades Collectibles is an independent retailer. We are not operated, sponsored, or endorsed by The Pokémon Company, Nintendo, Wizards of the Coast, Konami, Panini, Topps, PSA, BGS, or CGC. All trademarks belong to their respective owners.

Frequently asked questions

Which company is best?

The one whose holder you want for that card. We submit to all three and will talk it through.

What is a BGS subgrade?

BGS prints separate scores for centering, corners, edges, and surface on the label.

Do I need an account with the company?

Not for a PSA submission we send. We use our shop account. Ask us about the other two when you are at the counter.

Can the same card go to more than one company?

You pick one company per submission. If you crack a slab later, that holder is no longer a valid grade.

Where do I start?

Bring the card to 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187. Open daily, 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM.

Do you submit to PSA, BGS, and CGC?

Yes. The store FAQ and the grading page both say we handle submissions to all three and send them on your behalf.

What about SGC?

Sports pages list SGC among the graded slabs we stock. Submissions we send are PSA, BGS, and CGC.