Mystery squishies keep the design hidden until you open the bag — the same rip-and-reveal fun as our trading card mystery packs, in squishy form.

Because the contents are a surprise, we list exactly what a mystery item can contain on each product page rather than describing it vaguely.

Mini and tie-dye mystery dumplings are the most requested versions in store.

Stocked at 5021 Lee Highway, Warrenton, VA 20187. Open Daily 8AM–8PM.

Flat-rate US shipping. Free local pickup in Warrenton. There is no free-shipping threshold.